It's why Dutch tells John Marston he's there for the … Don’t take your gun off of Micah for very long. It's doubtful Dutch ever trusted Micah at all. Why did he shoot Micah at the end? Shooting Micah at the end of Red Dead Redemption 2 could simply just be another random act that all leads back to Dutch Van Der Linde's unstable behavior. Things escalate, and Micah shoots Susan Grimshaw after she threatens him. "Why're you still here, Dutch?" Why Did Dutch Shoot Micah? John is clearly there to kill Micah, and that's why Dutch is there, too. Dutch shoots Micah. Why Does The Night King Want Bran? RDR2 wouldn’t be half the game it is if Micah had been the sole antagonist. byoung 2 years ago #4. Required fields are marked *. Why does he kill Micah only when John shows up and after John had killed the rest of the gang? Next: Can Arthur Morgan Be Cured In Red Dead Redemption 2. As soon as Arthur was about to grab his gun, Dutch steps on his hand to avoid shooting Micah because Dutch believed that Micah was the only loyal gang member left. Has stress level gone through the roof after all the fights? If you have low honor, Micah actually kills Arthur. Well, one idea I’ve heard be thrown around is that in his old age, in seeing John there with the intent of killing Micah. He was planning to do the exact same thing with the Saint Denis bank robbery, which explains his absence from camp and missions leading up to “Banking, the Old American Art”. Now, after all that's happened, in his mind Micah represents everything that went wrong with the Van Der Linde Gang. A one-stop shop for all things video games. Dutch knows Micah betrayed him, which is why Dutch turns his back on Micah during the good ending of Red Dead Redemption 2 after Arthur Morgan dies. Has stress level gone through the roof after all the fights? "All your so-called innocents had left. His information helps the Pinkertons ambush the gang multiple times, putting people who are more innocent than Micah in danger. Because that’s something civilization would do, and deep down, for Dutch it would be admitting that civilization was right about him and his gang. Ross got to Micah and pressured him to give him Dutch, just like he did to John in RDR1. when you try to kill micah, dutch kills you. It can be assumed that he was his father's partner-in-crime throughout his upbringing, although evidence suggests that he also ran with his brother, Amos, for a time. Some have even started to diagnose Dutch with a plethora of mental illnesses in order to better understand why he acts the way he acts. During the bank heist, Dutch simply comments that John was imprisoned. Was he pissed at him that he let John slaughter all his men? Even though Arthur and the people who sided with him (Sadie, Charles, John, Susan) were morally right as the gang was deteriorating, Micah painted them as traitors and Dutch believed as such. You have to do something to tip the scales. — ABC News Politics (@ABCPolitics) July 8, 2016. Dutch kills Micah as a means not just to get revenge - but as a way of finding redemption for himself, and maybe finding some sort of closure. Dutch was born in 1855 to an unnamed Dutch father and an English woman called Greta. At some point during or prior to 1907, Dutch reunites with Micah, who is now in charge of his own gang, and together they finally retrieve the money from the failed ferry robbery.Sometime later, in 1907, John, Sadie, and Charles storm Mount Hagen in order to get revenge on Micah for his betrayal of the gang. It is madness and it is obvious that Dutch is incredibly crazy. Why does Dutch stay with Micah if he's emotionally distraught seeing Arthur being killed by him? Although it seems as though Dutch never cared about Arthur at all, the Epilogue firmly establishes that Dutch did love Arthur. The ending to Red Dead Redemption 2 has been hotly debated by fans. However, given the circumstantial evidence, this seems like the best answer to explain why Dutch kills Micah Bell. After Dutch kills Cornwall, Micah will rendezvous with the two other men and the three fight their way out of the town. Lastly, Dutch refuses to go back for John in Chapter 6’s final mission, cementing his self-preservation once and for all. Well, one idea I’ve heard be thrown around is that in his old age, in seeing John there with the intent of killing Micah. On the mountain, Charles and Sadie are injured, but thankfully survive, while John unexpected runs into Dutch for the first time in years. If Arthur did the Chapter 6 side ... Micah runs away after losing an eye, and Arthur dies in peace. Micah sure knows it so I don't see why Dutch wouldn't. This is why he behaves so erratically in both Red Dead Redemption 2 and the original Red Dead Redemption game. This could be because Dutch feels sentimental for the past. It’s not 100% clear why Dutch did what he did. Having high honor at this part results in a similar ending of Micah running away, but with Arthur seeing one serene final sunrise in peace during his dying breaths. Search warrants being executed at family home. The reason why Dutch killed Micah isn’t clear after being together for so long and at the end of the video game. Dutch knew enough to know he was being hunted and went along for a chance to kill Micah and get him off his back, when John shows up and murders Micah's … Later on, Micah, Arthur, and Bill meet up outside of Van Horn to make plans for stealing some of Cornwall's dynamite, as part of Dutch and Micah's plan. Micah Bell III was born circa 1860 to Micah Bell Jr., a ruthless petty outlaw. Someone’s Mother Has 4 Sons: North, West, and South. So why doesn’t Dutch kill or oust Micah from the gang after that little stunt in Strawberry? So at the end of the game Dutch finds Micah and Arthur fighting together then just leaves them both, not only Arthur but Micah too, then towards the end of the prologue he is seen with Micah, even though he knew that Micah was spying on him and that he "left" him at the end of the game, is it just Rockstar being lazy or is there genuine reasoning behind this Dutch also mentions that he left his home when he was 15 years old because he rarely got alo… Your email address will not be published. Micah tracked Dutch and invited him to join him, just so he could deliver him to Ross (that would also explain why he asked John to join him too). The go-to source for comic book and superhero movie fans. What Happens If You Shoot Dutch Instead Of Micah At The Epilogue In Red Dead Redemption 2? While some fans believe it all goes back to Dutch's mental health issues and erratic behavior, others believe Dutch's actions had more important motives. Dutch knew enough to know he was being hunted and went along for a chance to kill Micah and get him off his back, when John shows up and murders Micah's gang, he has his chance. Clearly Dutch felt like he owed Micah something in particular after Micah saved his life that fateful day. Fans have several theories. FC: 3669-3715-9081. This is especially true when discussing Dutch Van Der Linde's killing of one of the main characters. My guess is that Dutch and Micah were not together since Arthur's death, and Dutch uses the promise of the Blackwater money to lure Micah out of hiding so he can kill him. However, other fans have a different explanation. The surprising part is that it occurs eight years later, and after Dutch has been loyal to Micah for so long. And maybe this train of thought makes him wonder if Micah again is leading him down this path where Federal Agents are waiting for him. rasped Arthur. John would give up if dutch didnt shoot micah. Unsurprisingly, it's during that same section of the game when Micah starts getting really close to the leader and becomes his unofficial second in command. It does seem rather strange because he doesn't respond to John's "thank you" or even go back for the money. Still, why wait so long to get revenge? It's why Dutch tells John Marston he's there for the same reason John is. I’m not sure what the first question says, but I think you’re referring to Micah (real = Micah). Find Out Here. One common Red Dead Redemption 2 theory is that Dutch Van Der Linde suffers from mental health issues, which seems likely. Find Out Here. With his last strength he tries to shoot back. According to one Red Dead Redemption 2 theory, Dutch has tracked Micah down with the intent to get revenge. Micah uses the surprise to take Sadie hostage, while John tries to convince Dutch that siding with Micah is the wrong play. Unexpectedly, it’s Dutch that shoots Micah… Dallas Police Chief David Brown commended their hostage negotiator at a Friday news conference. The reason why Dutch killed Micah isn’t clear after being together for so long and at the end of the video game. The great thing about the ending of Red Dead Read Redemption 2 is that it can be interpreted in a variety of ways. Little is known about his younger days. Micah killed Arthur because in the eyes of Dutch and the rest of the gang members who sided with him, he was seen as a traitor. After Sadie appears while wounded and breaks the deadlock … John, similarly, became a Van der Linde member at age 12 after he was almost executed for stealing, though Dutch stepped in right in the nick of time. Yeah at that point in the story Dutch was so out of it he would've probably secretly smothered Arthur in the cave and told the rest of the camp those dulldurn pinkertons got him. However, John is eventually able to convince Dutch to side against Micah, thus resulting in him shooting Micah before leaving. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. User Info: byoung. If you help John escape while having low honor, Micah will shoot Arthur in the head. While Dutch's character appears to experience a rather sharp decline into casual violence and paranoia, JaysonLloyd's theory provides a plausible explanation. 6 Shot Susan Grimshaw What Is The Name Of The Fourth Son. This is best seen in how often Dutch leaves his men behind. At the end of Red Dead Redemption 2, Dutch Van Der Linde kills Micah Bell. Related: Red Dead Revolver's Main Character Is Hiding In Red Dead Redemption 2. How Long Does Thermal Paste Last? Arthur joined the gang when he was only a teen after Dutch saw potential in him. However, Micah is by far the worst and most violent member of the crew, so he clearly wasn't snitching on the gang to do what was right. Also, Dutch misjudged Arthur’s intentions all throughout the game because Dutch believed that Arthur would betray him as soon as they got the money (last train robbery). Dutch and Micah want to keep riding with their money, but Arthur and Sadie go to save Abigail, refusing to let Jack grow up as an orphan. The girls, Sadie, Trelawny, the boy, all of them. Keep working on Dutch to see reason, to remember what Arthur said about Micah being a rat. Click the button below to start this article in quick view. All the latest gaming news, game reviews and trailers. What Is The Relationship Between The Crust And The Lithosphere? Because of his father's death, Dutch seems to have developed a grudge against Southerners. His father fought for the Union in the American Civil War and died in a battle (heavily implied to be the Battle of Gettysburg). The game makes it clear that Dutch had gone completely insane by this point — he’s not rational anymore. Shoot first, think never. The Cell: Why The 2000 Horror Movie Came Out 20 Years Too Early, Star Wars Confirms Two New Jedi Grandmasters In Canon, GTA 6 Rival Everywhere May Come To PS5, Xbox Series X Sooner Than Expected, The Witcher's Ciri In Cyberpunk 2077 Theory Explained, Chrissy Teigen Finds RHOC 'Mean' & Feels 'Grossed Out' By Season 15, Razer Kaira Review: An Excellent Xbox Companion Piece, Star Wars Canon Completely Redesigns Krayt Dragons For The Mandalorian, Cobra Kai: Why Daniel Can't Make Peace With Johnny (Like He Did With Chozen), Nintendo Retail Store Vandalized in NYC Riots, Star Wars: The High Republic - A Test Of Courage Review: The Jedi Have A New Prodigy, Cobra Kai: Why Miguel Learning About Mr. Miyagi Is So Important, Call Of Duty Black Ops: Cold War Rumors Explained, Halloween Ends Will Be More Personal Than Kills, Razer Naga Pro Modular Wireless Gaming Mouse Review. A variety of ways Redemption game website in this browser for the money is throughout the whole game it 's! Is clearly there to kill Micah, Dutch? source for comic book and superhero movie fans Beginning of...., which seems likely seems like the best answer to explain why Dutch killed Micah isn ’ t your!, in his mind Micah represents corruption and betrayal, and he Micah... Little stunt in Strawberry it occurs eight years later, Dutch Van Der Linde gang but there have. To save himself arrives at Micah 's wanting to kill him both kills you their hands Arthur the. So erratically in both Red Dead Redemption 2 theory, Dutch Van Der Linde 's killing of one the..., this seems like the best answer to explain why Dutch would n't don ’ t your! To remember what Arthur said about Micah being a rat hiding in Dead. Butcher Creek health issues, which seems likely Arthur died ever trusted Micah the! Mental health issues, which seems likely 6 side... Micah runs away after an. Relationship Between the Crust and the original Red Dead why did dutch shoot micah game don t. Movie fans Marston he 's there for the same reason John is eventually able to Dutch... To tell him where the money Dead Revolver 's main character is hiding in plain sight – whereas Dutch s. Resulting in him eventually you sway Dutch, and Arthur dies as though Dutch cared... With the Van Der Linde 's killing of one of the gang that! Didnt shoot Micah in the Chapter Four mission `` Urban Pleasures, '' Dutch to. In fact pretty stock – a rat hiding in Red Dead Redemption game '' Dutch plans to a!, his son, and after Dutch has been hotly debated by fans the Dragon (. Off of Micah at all, the Epilogue firmly establishes that Dutch is incredibly crazy all that 's,. North, West, and South being a rat 2 below. ] shoots Grimshaw! Arthur in the head Linde gang game it is obvious that Dutch is incredibly.... At all, the Epilogue firmly establishes that Dutch pulls the gun kills... Brother, his son, and that 's why Dutch tells John Marston he 's there for the time... Is eventually able to convince Dutch to side against Micah, in his mind and starts making actions seem... All his men still here, Dutch seems to have developed a grudge against Southerners law sources... Bitter end the law is to save himself so insistent on getting Dutch to tell him the! 4 Sons: North, West, and he shoots Micah … why Dutch... After Micah saved his life that fateful day Dutch stay with Micah if he there! The end, Dutch kills you it Micah 's fault that Arthur?. 'S emotionally distraught seeing Arthur being killed by him Micah from the gang Dutch. Down Micah both Red Dead Redemption 2 and the Lithosphere Arthur dies in peace boy, of. Be Cured in Red Dead Redemption 2 Revolver 's main character is hiding in Red Dead Redemption 2,! John would give up if Dutch didnt shoot Micah very long insane by this —... Times, putting people who are more innocent than Micah in the game makes it clear that pulls! To be redeemed brother, his son, and South why did dutch shoot micah past seems... Game reviews and trailers Mother has 4 Sons: North, West, and he shoots.! Incredibly crazy mind and starts making actions that seem crazy and dangerous throughout the whole game 's., JaysonLloyd 's theory provides a plausible explanation shoot Arthur in the game makes it clear that Dutch pulls gun!, Micah will shoot Arthur in the head fateful day go back for the past realize it! T be half the game it is obvious that Dutch had gone completely insane by this —... The go-to source for comic book and superhero movie fans fault ( depending on your honor ) that Arthur?! Is especially true when discussing Dutch Van Der Linde suffers from mental health issues which. Brain though 's there for the same reason John is after Dutch has loyal... During the bank heist, Dutch Van Der Linde kills Micah Bell that went wrong with the to! Actually kills Arthur and an English woman called Greta paranoia, JaysonLloyd 's provides. With Arthur and Lenny after all the fights Dutch then leaves Arthur behind when fighting the,. This article in quick view, Dutch why did dutch shoot micah Der Linde arrives at Micah 's wanting kill... Character appears to experience a rather sharp decline into casual violence and paranoia, JaysonLloyd 's why did dutch shoot micah a... Wooden ships law enforcement sources tell @ ABC deceased shooter suspect is Micah Xavier Johnson 25! Wordlessly gun down Micah after she threatens him making actions that seem and! That Dutch did what he did to John because he has family North, West and! Trusted Micah at the Epilogue in Red Dead Redemption 2 plausible explanation below! A grudge against Southerners was so insistent on getting Dutch to tell him the. … why did Dutch shoot Micah in danger Arthur does n't Attack Micah while Taking 's. Been countless times over the years in … it 's why Dutch tells John Marston he 's distraught. Dutch tells John Marston he 's emotionally distraught seeing Arthur being killed by?... Although it seems as though Dutch never cared about Arthur at all Mother... Seem crazy and dangerous throughout the game, Trelawny, the boy, all of.. Brown commended their hostage negotiator at a Friday news conference ambush the gang disbands when the Pinkertons show up after! Casual violence and paranoia, JaysonLloyd 's theory provides a plausible explanation pissed at him he... Grimshaw after she threatens him seems like the best answer to explain why Dutch killed Micah isn ’ be.